Thursday, February 02, 2012

Eyeliner comparison (SANA, Maybelline, K-Palette, Dolly Wink)

Hello~~ ❤_❤, How are you ladies? I hope you're doing well!! I'm going to make a comparison between my eyeliner collection. Many people already asked me about this, sorry for make it so long~! ≧△≦ And I hope this review isn't make you bored ._.
This is my pen-type liquid eyeliner collection at the moment (Owh yeah, forget about the Etude one!).




I'm going to review this four eyeliner only. lol.



Here's the swatch. (1st-SANA, 2nd-Maybelline, 3rd-K-Palette, 4th-Dolly Wink).


SANA, natural black color. When dry the texture is like Maybelline, but Maybelline is look like using gel liner.
Maybelline, natural black color. When dry the texture is like a gel liner. Not glossy or look like rubber.
K-Palette, super black color. The only eyeliner that spread on to my skin, you can see it on the pictures. It just like an ink. 
Dolly Wink, super black color. Almost same like K-palette.


Which one is the most quick dry formula? Maybelline hypersharp liner.


✩ Rub with hands.
All of them are smudge-proof!




✩ Drop with water and rub it slowly. You can see which eyeliner is really waterproof.


. SANA, okay.
. Maybelline, doing well.
. K-Palette, okay.
. Dolly wink, I don't know why it's crack like that.


✩Tap it and dry it with fingers.


. SANA, okay, a bit washed..
. Maybelline, doing well. Bit washed too.
. K-Palette, when rub the eyeliner is become like flakes so it has a hole like that. But, it's really waterproof.
. Dolly Wink, a little bit cracked but it's okay.


Which one is the most water-proof out of them? K-Palette.


✩ Drop a eye make up remover. (I don't know why I'm doing this =x=)


✩ Wipes with a cotton.
--Okay, As you can see. K-Palette and Dolly wink looks a bit messy because of the flakes, but that's okay, this will happen only when you removes your eye make up.


✩ Clean all of it (you can see, it still has a little stain from the eyeliner).


I still love the Maybelline one. Why? For me, I prefer the natural black color which not too black and messy when cleaned. It's smudge-proof, water-proof and stay long on my eyelid but the bad thing, it doesn't stand my oily eyelid.




Actually, all of them are okay. But when use for hang out, this is the result based on my experience (may different on you or other people).
✩ The less water-proof : SANA
✩ The most water-proof : K-Palette
✩ Nice texture when applied : Maybelline
✩ Stay long : K-palette
✩ Quick dry : Maybelline
✩ Cutest packaging : Dolly Wink
✩ Boring packaging : I can't choose between Maybelline and K-Palette, LOL.


(This is based on me, you may have a different opinion or experience. So, you better try it by your self XD).


I hope this review helps you, sorry if it's too long @_@. I'm kinda confused when make a long review like this, mwahahahhah ≧△≦. See you~!

59 comments:

Amyboo said...

Oooo. This comparison is pretty helpful! :D <3 Thanks for sharing!

Nana said...

This is helpful! Thank you! 

jessa marie said...

This post is really helpful!!! you did a great job! Nice!


http://ilovemakeup68.blogspot.com/

-------------- said...

its really helpful my dear <3
i love all of them xD


gitasyalala.blogspot.com

xoxo,
G.R

miharu jhulie said...

banyak banget eyelinernya >__<"
btw thanks for sharing X"D nice !

Sunmi Unnie@Patsy said...

thx for the review,it's really hepful!(^_^)

Karina Dinda Rachmawati said...

Klo beli Maybelline yg itu di Indo gaada ya? Makasih yaaa perbandingannya, it's help me a lot :D

http://li-lo-la.blogspot.com

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcome, glad it helps! :D

♔cominica♔ said...

thank you! and you're welcome :D

♔cominica♔ said...

Thank youuuu :)

♔cominica♔ said...

sama2 XD, ah nggaa juga kokk>_<

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcome and thanks! *w*

NaTT SS said...

Awww, Really good review (even looks like fun, hahaha), But now it's really hard to decide for one! XDDD

monolidpanda said...

thank you for the review :)
i will try the K-palette eyeliner. :x
hope it stays on monolids!

Xiao said...

Maybelline is much easier for me to buy than the other brands, since I life in the Netherlands. Maybe I'm going to try the Maybelline one. Great review!

THT Christina said...

I think I like the dolly wink and maybelline ones the best, the k palette bleeding makes me stray away from it haha, this is a good comparison, I've wanted to know the properties of some of these. I need new eyeliner too haha

Samram1214 said...

excellent review!

http://samram1214.blogspot.com/ 

Hanbi Jang said...

I really like the nice black ones but they always flake for me ): I might try the maybelline one :D 

Thanks for the review <3

Mzx NiNi said...

Great review! Thanks :)

Mui Mui said...

Nice review! Thanks so much ^_^ I like the Maybelline and K-Palette one ^^)/

Anastasia said...

If only I knew how to apply eyeliner correctly! I'm following you,return love back?
xo
Anastasia

Rhea Bue said...

I love all of them! :D especially the 
K-Palette and DOllywink. :) I really prefer dark colored eye liners. hihihihihi :D

aiMee Bunbun said...

really lovely post! :D i learned a bunch hehe :3

http://amz88.blogspot.com/

Pitaloka Ramadina said...

Thanks for comparison :),
kayaknya positif naksir maybelline nih,  soalnya liat k-palette kaya flaky gitu ya. Bah, kebanyakan wishlist bikin bingung mau beli yg mana, kudu nabung en jaga mata dulu, kalo engga malah beli yg laen2 >.<
Oh iya, sekalian mau tanya dulu beli opera moist gloss berapaan yah? Baru nyadar ternyata nih lip gloss shimmer nya gold gitu ya? lagi demen lippies yg pake gold shimmer gara2 pake NYX rls indian pink :D

sujana said...

I like dolly wink the most!! I really like it when eyeliner is super black! Too bad cuz I don't think there's dolly wink eyeliner available in Canada :(

Dewi said...

This is so useful, thank you!! x

♔cominica♔ said...

lol, yeah! XD all of them is good but I don't like the SANA one, it's not waterproof.

♔cominica♔ said...

lmao bleeding! XD, 

♔cominica♔ said...

thank you :)

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcome :D
yeah I hope so! :)

♔cominica♔ said...

thank you :) , I'm sure you will love it

♔cominica♔ said...

Yeah, I don't really like flakes eyeliner. you're welcome :)

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcome :)

♔cominica♔ said...

thank you and you're welcome :D

♔cominica♔ said...

you can learn and it's not hard :D, of course ^^

♔cominica♔ said...

me too :D, aww I like natural black color now xD

♔cominica♔ said...

thank you :)

♔cominica♔ said...

ia pas apus nya aja siiihhh din :)
wkkwkwk iaaa susah ya jadi cw, hmm beli 60rb. iaa lipglossnya cakep warnanya, hehe :D

♔cominica♔ said...

aww you can buy online :D

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcome :D

my sister said...

thank you, very useful :D

Kimu said...

I've only ever tried the Dolly Wink one and I'm fairly happy with it. I'd like to try K-Palette though.. thanks for the comparisons!

Terry Hua said...

Thanks for the review~ :]

Yo She Phine said...

thanks for the review cominica~
now i know i won't buy k-palette !
lol..

♔cominica♔ said...

you;re welcome :D

♔cominica♔ said...

you're welcomee :D

♔cominica♔ said...

you;re welcome :D

♔cominica♔ said...

omg LMAO XDDD

Mukti Lim said...

wa thanks reviewnya..
muimiu.blogspot.com

J-Lene said...

Thanks for the review! I was so torn between K-Palette and Dolly Wink. Now I think I'm getting both of them XD

Pitaloka Ramadina said...

weh..60rb? murce juga ternyata, selama ini ga pernah mampir2 ke konter opera soalnya dari dulu kalo ngeliat kaya nya yg mampir ibu2 ato mba2 yg udah kerja, kirain mahal >.<

♔cominica♔ said...

iaaa murah kaann xD
gak mahal kok, hehe iya itu mereka mungkin liat skin care nya,kan dia ada line whitening gitu. hehe :)

rhen said...

nice demo. so which one's your personal fave?? I did a review on K-Palette. Check it out here: http://beautyanon.wordpress.com/2012/02/24/review-k-palette-real-lasting-eyeliner/

♔cominica♔ said...

sama2 ;)

♔cominica♔ said...

Hahaha yeah you should! XD

♔cominica♔ said...

In order : maybelline - dolly wink - k-palette - sana ^o^

cominica said...

what do u prefer to choose between maybelline hyper sharp liner and maybelline master liner? both are maybelline product but the texture of master liner is like a crayon.. which one's do u think the best? thank you :)

cominica said...

master liner?? I prefer liquid like hyper sharp :D

cominica said...

I was wondering if you have found an eyeliner thats good for oily lids.. I have very very oily lids, and even though I use a base, followed by liquid liner (Mac's/Dolly Wink etc), they always smudge after a few hours :( Helpppppp :'(

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...